The episode starts with Timmy disguising himself as a pizza delivery boy to impress Trixie Tang. But when he delivers the box, it turns out to be empty and Trixie sees through Timmy's crummy disguise, then sends him flying into a trash can (but not before accidentally catapulting herself into Vicky's house). Timmy is coming back home, depressed and tired, as Tootie shows up, trying to console him by going on a date, but Timmy refuses her offer, even when she puts on make-up and dresses exactly like Trixie. Back home, Timmy explains his failed plan to Cosmo, Wanda & Poof. He then wishes to switch lives with Trixie, believing he will have a better life, as Wanda poofs up a life-switching machine. Timmy uses the machine and wakes up in Trixie Tang's room. He is now wearing clothes similar to Trixie's, has cool toys, and lives in a mansion. Timmy then catches the school bus, and is gushed over by an alternate Trixie, who now lives Timmy Turner's life.